Heads up: links on this page go to each company’s own website. If you buy through one, Phasepost may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. That never changes our rankings — no brand can pay for a better spot. How we compare · Full disclosure

Medical Guardian vs Bay Alarm Medical

Bay Alarm Medical starts at $27.95/mo with no equipment fee on the home console and no contract. Medical Guardian starts at the same $27.95/mo on its annual landline plan, but you buy the equipment ($149.95) and commit to three months. Bay Alarm is the cheaper first year; Medical Guardian has more devices, including a smartwatch.

Prices last checked: November 19, 2026. Both companies' figures come from their published prices — see each brand's review page for sources.

Medical GuardianBay Alarm Medical
From (monthly)$27.95/mo$27.95/mo
Month-to-month starting price$31.95/mo$27.95/mo
Annual-plan starting price$27.95/mo$27.95/mo
Equipment fee$149.95 one-time$0 — included
Activation fee$0 — none$0 — none
Fall detection$10.00/mo$10.00/mo
First year, with fall detection$653.35$455.40
Contract3-month minimum commitmentNo long-term contract; cancel anytime
DevicesMGHome (landline or cellular), Guardian Flex (mobile button), MGMove (smartwatch), MGMini (small wearable).SOS Home (landline or cellular), SOS All-In-One 2 (home + away), SOS Micro (small mobile button), SOS Smartwatch, and bundle packages.
RangeUp to 1,400 ft from the base unit (home systems)800–1,000 ft from the base unit (SOS Home, per Consumer Reports)
BatteryUp to 32-hour backup battery (home); up to 5 days (mobile devices)32-hour backup battery (SOS Home); up to 72 hours (All-In-One 2); up to 36 hours (Micro); about 6–18 hours (Smartwatch)

Check Medical Guardian price Check Bay Alarm Medical price

Our take

Bay Alarm Medical wins on first-year cost and simplicity. Medical Guardian wins if you want a smartwatch or a mobile device with five-day battery life.

Read the full reviews