Medical Guardian vs Bay Alarm Medical
Bay Alarm Medical starts at $27.95/mo with no equipment fee on the home console and no contract. Medical Guardian starts at the same $27.95/mo on its annual landline plan, but you buy the equipment ($149.95) and commit to three months. Bay Alarm is the cheaper first year; Medical Guardian has more devices, including a smartwatch.
Prices last checked: November 19, 2026. Both companies' figures come from their published prices — see each brand's review page for sources.
| Medical Guardian | Bay Alarm Medical | |
|---|---|---|
| From (monthly) | $27.95/mo | $27.95/mo |
| Month-to-month starting price | $31.95/mo | $27.95/mo |
| Annual-plan starting price | $27.95/mo | $27.95/mo |
| Equipment fee | $149.95 one-time | $0 — included |
| Activation fee | $0 — none | $0 — none |
| Fall detection | $10.00/mo | $10.00/mo |
| First year, with fall detection | $653.35 | $455.40 |
| Contract | 3-month minimum commitment | No long-term contract; cancel anytime |
| Devices | MGHome (landline or cellular), Guardian Flex (mobile button), MGMove (smartwatch), MGMini (small wearable). | SOS Home (landline or cellular), SOS All-In-One 2 (home + away), SOS Micro (small mobile button), SOS Smartwatch, and bundle packages. |
| Range | Up to 1,400 ft from the base unit (home systems) | 800–1,000 ft from the base unit (SOS Home, per Consumer Reports) |
| Battery | Up to 32-hour backup battery (home); up to 5 days (mobile devices) | 32-hour backup battery (SOS Home); up to 72 hours (All-In-One 2); up to 36 hours (Micro); about 6–18 hours (Smartwatch) |
Check Medical Guardian price Check Bay Alarm Medical price
Our take
Bay Alarm Medical wins on first-year cost and simplicity. Medical Guardian wins if you want a smartwatch or a mobile device with five-day battery life.
Read the full reviews
- Medical Guardian review — full prices, devices, and contract terms.
- Bay Alarm Medical review — full prices, devices, and contract terms.
- Best medical alert systems — all eight systems side by side.
- Cost guide & calculator — work out the first-year total for either system.